What is SafetySynthesis?
The meaning of the noun synthesis (from the ancient Greek σύνθεσις) is the unification or combination of two or more entities that together results in something new; alternately, it may mean the activity of creating something out of something else that already exists. The meaning of safety synthesis is similarly the system quality that ensures that a system is able to succeed under varying conditions, so that the number of intended and acceptable outcomes is as high as possible. (This is obviously a paraphrase of the definition of resilience in Resilience Engineering.) This is however not a natural and stable condition, but an artificial and potentially unstable one.1 Safety is, with a paraphrase of Weick’s terminology, a ‘dynamic event’, hence something that must be created constantly and continuously. The basis is that which makes up everyday work and everyday existence. The synthesis of that, the bringing together of what individuals and organisations do on all levels and over time, is what creates safety – at least until a better term has been adopted.2 This synthesis has two different forms, a synthesis across organisational levels and a synthesis over time.
The synthesis across levels is relatively easy to explain. It means that one must understand the dependencies or couplings between everything that happens in an organisation or when carrying out an activity, no matter which levels of the organisation or types of work are involved. And it is of course necessary that the people who do the work understand that themselves, i.e., that the synthesis is part of what everyone does or at least that it is recognised by them.
The synthesis over time is more difficult to explain, but no less essential. In many kinds of activities – probably in all – synchronisation is important. This certainly goes for industries where safety (whether as Safety-I or as Safety-II) is a concern; it goes for services; for communication; for production – not least if it is lean - and so on. Synchronisation is achieved by organising the various productive processes to avoid delays (outputs arriving too early or too late), to ensure a better use of the resources (for instance, doing things in parallel so that the same preconditions do not have to be established twice), to coordinate transportation of matter and energy between processes and sites, and so on.
But synchronisation is not the same as synthesis. A synthesis - and thereby synesis - is first achieved when we understand how things really fit together, when we understand the variability of everyday performance (the approximate adjustments), and how this variability may wax and wane, leading to outcomes that mostly are as intended, hence beneficial but sometimes are unintended and potentially detrimental. A temporal synthesis cannot be achieved by exploring pairwise combinations of functions, even if it is done exhaustively. Neither can it be achieved by a bottom-up approach. Instead it requires a genuine top-down, synthetic perspective in the sense of being able to see (perhaps by serendipity rather than by combinatorics) when something new and useful has been achieved. Safety synthesis or synesis is the constant creating and maintenance of conditions that allow work to succeed on all criteria taken together.
(c) Erik Hollnagel, 2020